English 99/101/102 Essay’s Author:____________________

J. Roth

Peer Editing Evaluation Form—Summary-and-Response Essay

Directions: Please read through the draft before completing this form.

General

FDoes the essay meet the requirements of the assignment? Yes No

What is the title of the professional essay? ____________________________

Does the essay occasionally blend in words from the professional essay?

Yes No

Thesis and Paragraph 1

FIs the thesis sentence easy to locate? Yes No

F Is the thesis sentence a response to the professional essay? Yes No

FDoes the introductory paragraph have the five requirements of a summary-and-response essay? Author, title, summary, transition, thesis sentence

Body Paragraphs

FDoes each body paragraph have a clear topic sentence? Yes No

If not, which body paragraph(s) need repair?

Body Paragraphs (continued)

FIs each body paragraph unified (do all of the details belong?) Yes No

If not, which body paragraph(s) need repair?

FIs each body paragraph organized coherently (are the details and examples in an effective order?) Yes No

If not, which body paragraph(s) need to be reorganized?

FIs each body paragraph complete (are there enough details and examples?) Yes No

If not, which body paragraph(s) need more details and examples?

F Does the essay properly blend the professional essay’s words with it? Yes No

What do you think the draft still needs?

FWhat did you enjoy most about the essay?